12 Most Valuable Nickels Coins

12.) 1916 D Buffalo Nickel - $1,780

11.) 1874 Shield Nickel - $1,800

10.) 1873 Shield Nickel - $1,800

9.) 1938 Jefferson Nickel - $1,800

8.) 1877 Shield Nickel - $1,854

7.) 1886 Liberty Head V Nickel - $1,861

6.) 1912 S Liberty Head V Nickel - $1,945

5.) 1885 Liberty Head V Nickel - $2,328

4.) 1919 D Buffalo Nickel - $2,350

3.) 1872 Shield Nickel - $2,500

2.) 1920 S Buffalo Nickel - $2,500

1.) 1870 Shield Nickel - $3,000